Classic Cupcakes
from $24.00
InquireCustom bakes, made for you.
Cakes, cupcakes, cookies and more — made from home with quality ingredients and lots of care. Browse the menu, send an inquiry, and Cassie takes it from there with customer pickup in New Baltimore, MI (St. Clair County & Northern Macomb). Pickup address is shared after your order is confirmed.
Made From Home
Small-batch bakes from Cassie’s home kitchen — not a storefront.
Inquire Online
Browse the menu, send an inquiry — Cassie takes over every sale.
Customer Pickup
Pick up in New Baltimore after Cassie confirms your order and shares the address.
Shop Our Favorites
Made-to-order bestsellers — inquire with your preferences and Cassie will take over the sale.
Easy Online Ordering
Browse like a shop — Cassie personally takes over every sale.
- 1
Browse Treats
Explore cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and boxes on the menu.
- 2
Send an Inquiry
Pick options and tell Cassie what you need and when.
- 3
Cassie Confirms
She finalizes details, pricing, and payment — then shares the pickup address.
- 4
Customer Pickup
Pick up your bake at the address Cassie sends once your order is confirmed.
Customer Pickup
This isn't a walk-in bakery. All orders are for customer pickup in New Baltimore, MI — serving St. Clair County and Northern Macomb. You'll get the pickup address only after Cassie confirms your order.
Learn more
Need Something Custom?
Weddings, birthdays, showers — share your vision and Cassie will design a cake made just for your celebration.
Request a custom orderWhat Our Customers Are Saying
“The celebration cake was stunning and tasted even better. Pickup was easy and stress-free.”
“Ordered cupcakes for the office — everyone asked where they came from. Will order again!”
“Cassie made our custom sugar cookies for a baby shower. Beautiful work and so personal.”
Follow Along on Facebook
Real bakes from Cassie's Customs — see more on Facebook.
